Teikėjai, kurie savo tekste tiesiogiai nurodė būtent šį straipsnio numerį. Tai citata iš jų pačių teksto — ne mūsų vertinimas ir ne priežastinis ryšys.
| Kas | Šalis | Ką parašė |
|---|---|---|
| EDRi European Digital Rights | ES | | Tel. +32 2 274 25 70 | www.edri.org While data controllers at least pay some lip service to the information obligations of article 12 and 13, article 14 is extremely poorly complied with, both in the private and public sector. This is deeply concerning ↗ |
| Asociación Española de Economía Digital (Adigital) | ES | nting abuse, we would suggest tightening the understanding of the normative element of the offence “manifestly unfounded”, within Article 12 by having a non-exhaustive list of case groups. This would not be to the detriment of the data subject since the assump ↗ |
| Selbstregulierung Informationswirtschaft e.V. (SRIW) | DE | principle, e.g., in Art. 11.1 GDPR. Data subject rights may also be performed abusively, which is acknowledged by GDPR, e.g., in Art. 12.6 or Art. 12.5 GDPR. Art. 12.6 clarifies that doubts in respect of a data subject’s identity shall be good reason for reje ↗ |
| German Insurance Association | DE | essure or Seite 4 von 18 harassment, should be included as standard examples of a non-existent right to information in Art. 15 or Art. 12 para. 5 GDPR. ↗ |
| Confederation of Swedish Enterprise | SE | strictly for reasons of data protection, and not be considered an absolute right. One way to address this issue could be to amend Art. 12 (5) GDPR, regulating manifestly unfounded or excessive requests. The EDPB Guideline on Right of Access needs to be updated ↗ |
| Spolek pro ohranu osobních údajů | CZ | rmation requested. A more straightforward interpretation of the controllers options to handle data subjects requests according to Art. 12 (5) is needed. "Excessive and unfounded" should be interpreted also in line with the availability of data processed throug ↗ |
| ANITEC-ASSINFORM | IT | swer – Detailed 1. There is a lack of clarity on what comprises a request that is manifestly unfounded or excessive: Art. 12(5) GDPR allows controllers to reject requests that are manifestly unfounded or excessive, or to charge a reasonable fee fo ↗ |
| — | FR | Shield était invalidé depuis des années et le DPF inexistant… … … Que dire ? Quand, dans le cadre de mes demandes d’information (article 12), je vois des DPO défendre mordicus que des liens et des images de traçage dans les emails constituent des stats agrégé ↗ |
| Bundessteuerberaterkammer | DE | roffenen Personen usw.). Informationspflichten, einschließlich Art und Detaillierungsgrad der bereitzustellenden Infor- mationen (Artikel 12 bis 14), Umsetzung der Anforderung des EuGH zur Benennung der kon- kreten Empfänger. Bitte geben Sie nach Möglichkeit e ↗ |
| The Information Technology Industry Council (ITI) | US | uch resolution. Greater clarity is needed on what constitutes a data subject request that is “manifestly unfounded or excessive” (Article 12(5) GDPR). This would help reduce the current administrative burden of proving the inadmissibility of such requests, and ↗ |
| Observatorio Internacional de Derechos Humanos del Ilustre y Nacional Colegio de Abogados de México | ME | países: • Argentina (art. 12 ley n. 25.326 de protección de datos personales, art. 12 del decreto reglamentario n. 1558/2001 y Disposición n 60). • Brasil (arts. 33 a 35 de la Ley general de Protección n de Datos). • Cabo Verde (art. 20, Ley no 41/VIII/2013, ↗ |
| Bundesrechtsanwaltskammer | DE | 3), Art. 103 (1) GG, Art. 2 (1) in conjunction with Art. 1 (1) GG in conjunction with Art. 1 (1) GG, Art. 8 (1) ECHR, Art. 7 CFR, Art. 12 (1) GG. It primarily serves to protect the client and his access to justice. Lawyer-client confidentiality protects victim ↗ |
| Bitkom e.V. | DE | ta subject and the scope of the right. The need for clarification on the concept of "manifestly unfounded or excessive" requests (Art. 12(5)) is evident, along with the necessity to strike a balance between the right to access and the protection of personal da ↗ |
| 5Rights Foundation | GB | ted by the child. Age Appropriate Design Code (UK) 6. Transparency and enabling of rights Transparency obligations are set out in Article 12 of the GDPR, which requires information to be provided to the data subject “in a concise, transparent, intelligible and ↗ |
| Bundesvereinigung der Deutschen Arbeitgeberverbände | DE | meldung zum Bericht über die Datenschutz-Grundverordnung Schwerpunkt der Stellungnahme: Beschäftigtendatenschutz 08. Februar 2024 Art. 12 Angesichts der zunehmenden Anzahl an Auskunftsersuchen ist die Frist für die Auskunftserteilung zu kurz. Sie sollte mindes ↗ |
| Verband der öffentlichen Wirtschaft und Gemeinwirtschaft Österreichs (VÖWG) | AT | er nicht mehr identifiziert werden kann, sollte angedacht werden, gewisse Erleichterungen iSd DSGVO zu erwirken. ErwG 39 & 58 iVm Art. 12 & 15: Besonders im technischen bzw. medizinischen Bereich stehen Verantwortliche bei z.B. Auskunftsbegehren gem. Art. 15 v ↗ |
| BDI e.V. (Federation of German Industries) | DE | cised strictly for reasons of protection of personal data, and not be considered an absolute right. Therefore, a clarification of Article 12 (5) GDPR (manifestly unfounded or excessive requests) is necessary: - attempts at gathering information in a pre-litiga ↗ |
| United Internet | DE | le parties can comply with their information obligations under Art. 13 and 14 of the GDPR and enforcing data subject rights under Art. 12 ff of the GDPR, especially in the processing of sensitive data under Art. 9 GDPR, remain key considerations. On the other ↗ |
| Insurance Europe | BE | e case of a data-loss event and therefore should not be included in the scope of the right of access. • The guidelines state that Art. 12 (5) on manifestly unfounded requests should be interpreted narrowly and that an access request should not be regarded as e ↗ |
| World Employment Confederation | BE | f access should be exercised for legitimate personal data protection purposes and not as an absolute right. Clarification of GDPR Article 12(5) is needed to avoid excessive gathering of information, e.g. ↗ |
| ZKI e.V. | DE | als auch die Verantwortlichen spürbar entlasten. Die Einführung von standardisierten Bildsymbolen für betroffene Personen gemäß Art. 12 Abs. 7, 8 DSGVO sollte weiter vorangetrieben und abgeschlossen werden. Insbesondere sollte die Möglichkeit der Nutzung von ↗ |
| Berufsverband der Datenschutzbeauftragten Deutschlands (BvD) e.V. | DE | dern gemäß Art. 5 Abs. 2 i.V.m. Abs. 1 lit. a DSGVO muss auch dokumentiert werden, dass diese Pflichten erfüllt werden, und gemäß Art. 12 DSGVO müssen – unabhängig von der Unternehmensgröße – nachweislich Maßnahmen implementiert werden, um diese Transparenzpfl ↗ |
| Ministerium für Wirtschaft, Industrie, Klimaschutz und Energie des Landes Nordrhein-Westfalen | DE | aftlichen Betrieb erheblich zu beeinträchtigen. Die Kommission wird gebeten zu prüfen, ob über die Formulierung „insbesondere“ in Art. 12 Abs. 5 S. 2 DS-GVO auch das kollusive Zusammenwirken mehrerer Antragstellenden als missbräuchlich im Sinne der Norm einges ↗ |
| DATEV eG | DE | information fatigue. This can be achieved with the the implementation of standardised symbols as proposed in Art. 12 (8), which the EU-Commission has yet to put forward. Making the GDPR more SME-friendly Furthermore, SMEs in particular have difficulties to ful ↗ |
| Media Scope Group OÜ | EE | , it is proposed that information relevant to data protection be clustered and standardised symbols be implemented as proposed in Article 12 (8) of the GDPR. Making the GDPR more SME-friendly Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in particular have difficu ↗ |
| Nicolas VINOT | FR | e 17) — Présence de traceurs ou de cookies non techniques (article 6) — Retard ou absence de réponse suite à une demande d’accès (article 12 & 15) — Réponse incomplète sinon vide suite à une demande d’accès (article 12 & 15) Les articles concernés sont parmi l ↗ |
| Anonos Inc. | US | session of “Additional Information” necessary for re-identification satisfy this requirement. b. Pseudonymization helps to enable Article 12(2) relaxation of obligations under Articles 15 (Right of Access by Data Subject), 16 (Right to Rectification), 17 (Righ ↗ |
| Hans-Hermann Schild | DE | in den Fällen der vollständigen oder teilweisen Ablehnung die Anhörung des Beschwerdeführers durchführen soll (Art. 12 VO-E) und bei einer vollständigen oder teilweisen Abweisung der Beschwerde wiederum die Aufsichtsbe- hörde, bei der die Beschwerde eingelegt ↗ |
| noyb | AT | admissible after (1) the data subject has provided a written request to the controller and (2) the 1-month period foreseen under Article 12(3) GDPR for the controller to answer has passed. When the issue is precisely that the data subject cannot identify the ↗ |
| Border Violence Monitoring Network | DE | nd processing of the data collection is to be provided in a “concise, transparent, intelligible and easily accessible form” under Article 12. It is impossible to fulfil this obligation if the information is not conveyed in a language which the relevant party u ↗ |
Šaltinis: viešų konsultacijų atsiliepimai ir pozicijų dokumentai. n = 45 paminėjimų; skaičiuojama pažodinė nuoroda į straipsnio numerį.